Wednesday, 25 September 2013
Photoshop Fiascos: When Retouching Jumps the Shark
Advertising can be traced back as early as the ancient Egyptian period, but really got going in the 19th century. During that time many ads were done using paintings of figures to demonstrate an ideal quality for the product being sold. Presently, most advertising uses photographs to promote the product but the idealisation still remains. The argument that arises is whether or not marketing agencies should be held accountable for misrepresenting a model or retouching to the point of excess. Personally, I believe that if the purpose of ads is to encourage, persuade or manipulate its audience into taking a specific action, then the imagery should contain certain aesthetics that defy reality. If a car ad was seen in the paper with rust and cracked fenders, there is a good chance that they wont make the sale. However, when retouching is applied to the human figure, specifically for women, the advertisement is attempting to sell an ideal quality or esteem that is attainable through buying their product and, lets face it, the exaggeration is terribly obvious to the trained eye. However, to those who have not yet learned apparently 'fundamental truths', these depictions of beauty can be taken to extremes and come at great cost. The death rate of young girls with eating disorders aged 15-24 is around 20% in Ontario alone (stats). This is an unsettling truth and something that strikes close to home.
The ideal form has been socially placed using art since the Renaissance, where buxom beauties were tastefully painted in the nude without embarrassment or apprehension. Back then I suppose having enough food to be a healthy weight was a status symbol as it meant you were wealthy enough to eat. This 'ideal physique' fluctuates through time and Marilyn Monroe was a groundbreaking icon who didn't mind showing a little thigh. But it seems as time progressed, the ideal form has taken a reduction, most likely because the consumer had to spend their last pay-check on that new Aritzia jacket and has no money for supper. But all joking aside, like it or not, ads promote an identity that young people strive for and thus marketing agencies should take a little candor in how they deliver their messages and to whom they are directed. As communication becomes more accessible with improved technology the media can be viewed by just about anyone and their younger sibling, posing the problem of how to focus on a certain demographic when everyone is drinking from the same stream. This problem may also be a solution, as people are now given control over their own media consumption and can pursue their own interests. The information highway has no speed limit, at least in our country...so far, and I have been witness even now to the increasing intelligence of our youth. I only hope that such epidemics as eating disorders and ignorant bullying can be quelled by our present society so that future generations can prosper on a self-actualized pedestal of personal pride and self-worth. Without those pillories, we might yet have a chance. Take it away Sir Mix-A-Lot!
Wednesday, 18 September 2013
Mic Mac Paddy Wack
The first on the chopping block is the "Back to School" ad campaign for the Mic Mac Mall in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia.
This campaign was not received well in the town of its release, and I do see how it could be considered demeaning to young women, but in today's uptight, politically correct society we could use a little controversy. In the case of Mic Mac Mall, I do not think its entirely fair that they take the heat for the 'distasteful' use of humour as it was devised on the other side of the country (Vancouver) where competition is much higher, but as the gatekeepers, they are the first to be burned by the angry mob.
As far as the message goes, I think its target audience would get a good laugh and I think its cartoonish aesthetic attests to the humorous strategy that the campaign was intending. The slim model-like features of the characters in the ad do give me some hesitation as I think young women are too often barraged by 'idealistic' forms, but this is a minor detail that is slowly being resolved in many advertisements showcasing plus-sized models.
Overall, I think the design of the campaign is playful and eye-catching and the clever use of puns assumes that an intelligent audience will look past the 'ditzy' facade and recognize the aim of the strategy to get shoppers into the store.
Wednesday, 4 September 2013
Symbology of a knave
The Jack of Spades is known for his education, training and love of his craft; his intentions right and honourable. He also has a darker side, cunningly shrouded in secrecy and irresponsibility (http://www.metasymbology.com/). This blog aims to reveal some of the traits within advertising that both awe and disgust us as we are assailed by the ever-present consumerism that we endure in a capitalist nation. I will be looking at hierarchy, symbolism, psychology and other selling topics while investigating the depths and heights to which some ads go to in order to fulfill their goal – convincing us of what we need to be happy. I will be playing the role of the Jack of Spades, in an attempt to divulge some of my own dormant wants and crystallized needs. I hope to bring this forum into a realm of discussion so that the voice of the masses can also be heard. We are all just cards in a deck waiting to be played to win the pot of everlasting bliss, and marketing be the chips... but you can't eat just one ;vp.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
